Abraham v Commissioner of State Revenue [2026] VCAT 351
Background
The Commissioner assessed Mrs H Abraham (the taxpayer) to land tax for the 2023 land tax year for land situated in Lorne (the land).
It was not disputed that the land was not the taxpayer’s principal place of residence at the time, but rather the family holiday home. The taxpayer contended that the Commissioner should have assessed the trustees of her late husband’s estate on the 50% interest in the land in lieu of herself.
Section 11 of the Land Tax Act 2005 (Land Tax Act) provides that a person who holds a life estate in possession in land is deemed to be the owner of the land, instead of the person entitled to the fee simple (in reversion or remainder).
Issue
Whether the taxpayer held a life estate in possession in and was therefore deemed to be the owner of 50% of the interest in the land instead of the trustees of the estate of her husband, the late Mr I Abraham.
Decision
On 18 May 2026, the Tribunal found in favour of the Commissioner, confirming the assessment.
The Tribunal concluded that clause 3 of the Will conferred a life estate in possession on the taxpayer in respect of Mr Abraham’s half share of the land for the purpose of section 11 of the Land Tax Act.
In reaching its decision, the Tribunal had regard to:
- the words used in clause 3, particularly in granting the taxpayer the right to ‘use and occupy’ the land during her lifetime
- “the context of the Will as a whole, noting that there is no language employed that is apt (individually or collectively) to displace the general rule of construction that a grant of a right to ‘use and occupy’ land confers a life estate”
- the nature of the land (i.e. a holiday house) and the obligations imposed on the taxpayer to maintain it and cover the costs of rates and taxes, which was more consistent with a secure and ongoing interest than a right to reside, which may or may not be taken up and could be lost by a failure to do so.