Delma Investments Pty Ltd (ACN 004 475 498) v Commissioner of State Revenue [2026] VSCA 53
Background
The taxpayer had owned land (the land) at Woodstock, a suburb in Melbourne’s north, since 1966. At all relevant times, the taxpayer had 4 directors who were all related and included Mr David Douglas.
They were also the only shareholders in the taxpayer, in equal shareholdings of 51/204 ordinary share. As at 2019, 3 of those shareholders were either close to or over 70 years old.
The land is located in an urban zone in greater Melbourne and comprises 310 acres and has 6 paddocks. The land had been used for farming activities by the Douglas family since it was first acquired, but had recently been sold for the sum of $50 million.
The taxpayer objected to the 2020 and 2021 land tax assessments on the basis that the land was exempt under s67 of the Land Tax Act 2005 (Land Tax Act). The taxpayer submitted that the land was:
- used primarily for the business of primary production (cattle) (s67(1)(a)(iii))
- the business was the principal business of the taxpayer (s67B(1)(b))
- Mr Douglas was normally engaged in a substantially full-time capacity in the business of primary production carried out on the land (s67B(2)(a)(ii)(B)) (the engagement issue).
If any of the above elements were not met, the land would not be exempt land under s67 of the Land Tax Act.
Decision – Supreme Court (earlier decision)
On 25 October 2024, the Supreme Court handed down the decision substantially in favour of the Commissioner (Delma Investments Pty Ltd v Commissioner of State Revenue [2024] VSC 649).
While the Supreme Court found that the land was used “primarily for the business of primary production” and the principal business of the taxpayer was the “business of primary production”, it determined “Mr Douglas was not normally engaged in a full-time capacity in Delma’s business of primary production” (s67B(2)) – and therefore affirmed the assessments.
Decision – Court of Appeal (current decision)
On 6 December 2024, the taxpayer applied for leave to appeal the decision to the Court of Appeal on the engagement issue and submitted that the words ‘normally engaged in a substantially full-time capacity’ should take their meaning by reference to the ‘requirements’ of the business in issue.
On 27 March 2026, the Court of Appeal handed down the decision in favour of the Commissioner.
In summary, the Court of Appeal found that:
- the taxpayer’s “construction found no support whosoever in the language of the relevant provision”
- “the concept of being in a ‘substantially full-time capacity’ is an ordinary phrase readily understood as applying to a person such as an employee, or contractor and measured by reference to commonly understood community standards … The phrase does not import any reference to the ‘needs’ of the business or anything like it. It simply identifies where the purpose must be engaged, namely, ‘in the business’.”
The Court of Appeal concluded that the taxpayer’s construction was “therefore not available on the language of the provision.”