Skip to Content
State Revenue Office
Log in

Guan v Commissioner of State Revenue [2026] VCAT 290

Background

In 2014, Mr Guan became the registered proprietor of a property in Balwyn North.

In 2019, he transferred the property to himself and his wife Mrs Li (the taxpayers) as joint tenants.

The Commissioner originally exempted the transfer under s43 of the Duties Act 2000 (Duties Act), which exempts from duty some transfers of a principal place of residence (PPR) between spouses.

A specific requirement is that a person occupies the residence for a continuous period of at least 12 months commencing within a 12-month period immediately after the transfer (the residence requirement).

Issue

Whether, following an investigation, the Commissioner had correctly reassessed the taxpayers to duty, penalty and interest on the basis that exemption requirements in s43A of the Duties Act (the residence requirement) had not been met.

Decision

On 29 April 2026, the Tribunal handed down its decision. The Tribunal partially reduced the penalty tax but otherwise confirmed the reassessment. The Tribunal found the following:

  • The taxpayers did not meet the residence requirement after the transfer (as required by s43A), notwithstanding that they had been using the property as their PPR for a couple of years prior to the transfer.
  • There was no good reason to vary the residence requirement in this instance, and the power to vary the residence requirement does not permit the Commissioner or the Tribunal to vary it such that no period of residence is required after the transfer.
  • In relation to penalty tax, the information provided by the taxpayers in relation to the prior land tax investigation was a ‘pre-investigation’ disclosure, such that the reduction in section 31(1) of the Taxation Administration Act 1997 applied. Therefore, the penalty tax of 25% was reduced to 5%.

When considering the remission of penalty and the requirements of ‘reasonable care’, it also observed: “A reasonable person in their situation would have been aware that property transactions usually attract a tax duty. A reasonable person would have taken affirmative steps to fully familiarise themselves with the any potential tax obligations arising from the transfer of the Balwyn property. This is the case regardless of the person’s English proficiency. A reasonable person would not have relied on statements from an estate agent only, and would have sought expert advice and made further inquiries.”

The Tribunal also remarked: “A misunderstanding of the law is not a basis for remission of the penalty tax.”

In relation to interest, the Tribunal concluded it was not appropriate to remit the market interest imposed in the assessment.

Updated: 18 November 2026