Skip to Content
State Revenue Office
Log in

Kumar v Commissioner of State Revenue (Review and Regulation) [2025] VCAT 695

Background

In August 2017, Mr Kumar and Mrs Kumari (the taxpayers) entered an off-the-plan contract of sale to purchase residential land in Avondale Heights in Victoria (the relevant property). At the time they lived and worked in Western Australia.

Issue

Whether, following an investigation, the Commissioner was correct to reassess the taxpayers on the basis that:

  • the taxpayers were not eligible for the off-the-plan and principal place of residence (PPR) concessions, and
  • penalty tax at a rate of 90% should be imposed because the taxpayers had intentionally disregarded a taxation law and took steps to prevent or hinder the Commissioner from becoming aware of the nature and extent of the tax default.

Decision

On 4 August 2025, the Tribunal handed down its decision in favour of the Commissioner, confirming the reassessment to duty, including imposition of 90% penalty tax and interest.

In the circumstance, the Tribunal was comfortably satisfied that:

  • the taxpayers did not occupy the relevant property as their PPR (or at all) for a continuous period of 12 months commencing within 12 months of its acquisition and therefore did not satisfy the residence requirement
  • having regard to all of the circumstances, there was no ‘good reason’ to exercise the discretion in s57L to extend the time to start the necessary period of occupation
  • having regard to the taxpayers’ conduct during the investigation and in respect of the objection and review process, the penalty had been appropriately imposed at the rate of 90% and there was no basis for remission of the penalty tax or interest.
Updated: 18 November 2026