Skip to Content
State Revenue Office
Log in

Richwol v Commissioner of State Revenue (Review and Regulation) [2025] VCAT 1065

Background

This matter concerns the liability of Ms K Richwol (the taxpayer) for land tax as a registered proprietor of a 50% interest in land in Brighton East – Lot 11A (11A Land), which her sister-in-law occupied as her principal place of residence (PPR).

The taxpayer accepted she used and occupied the neighbouring land (11B Land) as her PPR, for which she had already claimed the PPR exemption under s54 of the Land Tax Act 2005 (Land Tax Act).

The taxpayer initially contended she held her 50% interest in the 11A Land on trust for her sister-in-law who was using the 11A Land as her PPR, and it should therefore be exempt under s54.

The taxpayer’s submissions changed at the hearing, where she contended she was not an owner of 50% of the 11A Land within the meaning of s10(1) of the Land Tax Act – on the basis she was not a ‘person entitled to land for a freehold estate in possession’ on the basis her sister-in-law had exclusive rights to use the 11A Land.

Issue

Whether the taxpayer was liable to land tax in respect of her 50% interest in the 11A Land for the 2023 land tax year.

Decision

On 3 December 2025, the Tribunal confirmed the assessment of the taxpayer to land tax for the 2023 land tax year on the taxpayer’s half share of the 11A Land.

In reaching its decision, the Tribunal considered various authorities which considered the meaning of the terms ‘owner’ and ‘estate in possession’.

The Tribunal took the view that as one of the 2 registered proprietors of the 11A Land, the taxpayer had a present right of beneficial enjoyment even though she allowed her sister-in-law and her family to have exclusive use and occupation of the land.

It followed that, for land tax purposes:

  • the taxpayer was an owner of the 11A Land
  • the taxpayer and her sister-in-law were joint owners of the 11A Land
  • the taxpayer was liable to land tax on the taxpayer’s half share of the 11A Land because she did not use and occupy that land as her PPR.
Updated: 18 November 2026