Skip to Content
State Revenue Office
Log in

Tran v Commissioner of State Revenue (Review and Regulation) [2025] VCAT 581

Background

On 20 December 2017, Ms Tran (the taxpayer) completed the purchase, and became the registered proprietor, of a residential property in Werribee (the property) on 10 January 2018.

The taxpayer indicated in her Transferee Statement that she intended to occupy the property as her principal place of residence (PPR) from completion and claimed the PPR concessions and first home buyer exemption (the duty benefits) under the Duties Act 2000 (Duties Act). As a result, the Commissioner charged no duty on the transfer.

Following a later investigation, the Commissioner determined that the taxpayer had not met the requirements of the duty benefits and reassessed the taxpayer to duty, and imposed a penalty of 25% and interest.

Issue

Whether:

  • the taxpayer satisfied the residence requirement in s57K of the Duties Act, and lived in the property as her PPR for a continuous period of 12 months commencing within 12 months of becoming entitled to possession, and therefore was entitled to:
    • the PPR concessional rate, and
    • the first home buyer duty exemption in respect of the transfer
  • the Commissioner correctly imposed penalty tax and interest on the taxpayer.

Decision

On 3 July 2025, and after further post-hearing written submissions from the parties, the Tribunal handed down written reasons for decision, determining that:

  • the taxpayer did not discharge her onus of proving, on the balance of probabilities, that she satisfied the residence requirement in s57K of the Duties Act
  • the Tribunal does not have a discretion under s57M(1)(b) of the Duties Act in relation to the reassessment of duty where the residence requirement has not been satisfied
  • while the taxpayer did not take reasonable care to comply with her tax obligations, it is appropriate to remit the penalty tax from an effective rate of 25% to 10% having regard to the treatment of first home owner grants and taking account of all the taxpayer’s circumstances
  • the interest which accrued to the date of the assessment should not be remitted.

The Tribunal concluded: “That is not to say that Ms Tran never visited the Relevant Property. However, she has not provided any proper explanation, and supporting evidence, for the low utility usage. That low usage is more consistent with merely sleeping at the property, which the cases establish is insufficient to satisfy the Residence Requirement.”

Further: “As indicated in Mercuri v Commissioner of State Revenue, entry into an exclusive leasing authority within the period necessary to satisfy the Residence Requirement for leasing to start after that period is:

  • ‘more consistent with an intention to hold the Unit for investment than as a [principal place of residence]’; and
  • ‘[v]iewed objectively … [consistent with] going through a “ritual of occupancy … necessary to get the grant”.’”
Updated: 18 November 2026