Skip to Content
State Revenue Office
Log in

Zhu v Commissioner of State Revenue (Review and Regulation) (Corrected) [2025] VCAT 926

Background

This matter concerns the liability of Ms Y Zhu (the taxpayer) for land tax and vacant residential land tax. The taxpayer had purchased a property in Forest Hill (the land), with settlement occurring in December 2021.

Following an investigation, the Commissioner determined that the land did not qualify as the taxpayer’s principal place of residence (PPR) for the 2022 and 2023 land tax years due to her limited occupancy. This led to an assessment of land tax for the 2022 year and an assessment of land tax and vacant residential land tax for 2023.

Issue

Whether:

  • the taxpayer met the criteria for a PPR exemption for the 2022 and 2023 land tax years
  • the land was vacant residential land for the 2023 land tax year.

Decision

On 22 October 2025, the Tribunal handed down its decision, confirming the reassessments to both land tax and vacant residential land tax for the relevant years.

The Tribunal found that the objective evidence suggested that the taxpayer and her late husband continued to reside at their daughter’s home until in or around March 2023 when they hired a van and moved their household effects to the land.

The Tribunal observed: “the evidence of utilities usage at the Relevant Property is only consistent with Ms. Zhu’s initial explanation (i.e. in her May 2023 Correspondence) as to the use of that property prior to March 2023, namely that she and her husband:

  • would visit the property on weekends to garden and conduct other maintenance, but,
  • otherwise spent the majority of their time eating, sleeping and engaging in the other activities of life (e.g. showering) at their daughter’s house.”
Updated: 18 November 2026